ROUGH CUT REVIEW

TV6 min readPublished Updated

Dark Matter Episode Nine Review: Four Goes Missing

“Episode Nine” of Dark Matter, first aired on Syfy on August 7, 2015, sends the crew of the Raza after Four when he vanishes to confront his past. It is a character-driven hour that spends as much time on a quiet argument between Five and Six as on its rescue plot.

Dark Matter Episode Nine Review: Four Goes Missing 01:06:00:00
01Scene 01

Dark Matter episode nine review

Nine episodes into its first season, Dark Matter has a clear policy: the story belongs to the six people on the Raza, and everyone else is passing through. “Episode Nine” follows that rule closely. The hour is built around Four, the ship's silent fighter, who leaves the ship to meet his half-brother Hiro. One, Two and Three decide to go and get him, while Five and Six work out what they are to each other on board.

The series, created by Joseph Mallozzi and Paul Mullie from their own comic, starts from a simple situation. Six people wake up on a spaceship with no memory of who they are, and they name themselves by the order in which they woke up: One through Six. The Android, played by Zoie Palmer, runs the ship and helps them learn that they may have been criminals. Each episode so far has pulled one member's backstory into view, and this one is Four's turn.

Four, played by Alex Mallari Jr., is the character with the least to discover about himself, and that is what makes his episode interesting. Unlike the rest of the crew, he knows his own history, which is that he is Ishida Ryo, crown prince of Zairon. The memory loss that defines the others does not define him. So when he disappears, the question the crew has to answer is not who he is but why he would stay with them at all.

The debate over that is the best scene of the first act. One argues that Four owes the crew an explanation for walking out. Three, who is usually the one to say something cynical, answers that nobody on the ship owes anyone anything. It is a surprising line from a man who keeps a running tally of the lives he has saved, but it is accurate. The crew is held together by the hope of one day learning where they came from, and Four already knows. Nothing forces him to stay.

Four, Hiro and the trap

Most of the hour follows Four's journey, and it fills in the picture with his mentor Akita-san and his relationship with his brother and father. Four has always been a stern figure, but the episode shows his compassion, and a protectiveness toward the people he cares about that matches Three's. Both men keep it guarded, and that shared reserve makes them a natural pair.

The trap is set by his family. Four is arrested by Akita when he comes to meet Hiro, who has become Emperor, and the crew has to find a way to get him out. Three sees the rescue as a chance for growth for himself and the group, and Two and One go along. The rescue plan is not elaborate, and the episode wisely does not pretend it is. The point is the decision to go, not the mechanics of the breakout.

The ending is the surprise. Four kills Akita as a message to Hiro, a moment that undercuts the sympathetic version of the character the hour has been building. It is the kind of choice that the others will have to live with, and the final scene, in which three Ferrous Corp destroyers disable the Raza's faster-than-light drives, makes sure the consequences begin right away.

One and Three, still at war

The most hostile pairing on the show is One and Three, and the week before this episode ended on a cliffhanger that made the feud personal. One learned that his life before the memory wipe included a wife, and that Three may have killed her. He does not handle it well in “Episode Nine,” and the show is not subtle about it. His distress is easy to see, and Two, who has the job of managing him, tells him to get over it because he does not even remember the woman.

That line is harsh but practical, and it fits Two's approach. One cannot get past it, even after everything the crew has been through, and at one point he considers shooting Three. When Three recounts the “score” between them at the end, there is hope that the feud might finally cool. Knowing One, it will not, and the viewer's patience with the storyline is getting tested. The idea is sound, since it gives the group a fault line, but the character spends the hour sulking, and at some point the story has to move forward.

Five and Six: the best scene of the hour

While Four is being stabbed and threatened elsewhere, Five asks Six to teach her how to defend herself. The request is reasonable, because life on the Raza is never calm. Six, like the others, sees Five as a child and refuses, and Five snaps back that the crew's enemies do not spare her because of her age, and that she has nearly died for them a few times already.

Six apologizes later, in what is one of the warmest scenes of the season. Jodelle Ferland as Five and Roger Cross as Six play it without a trace of sentimentality, and the exchange works because both of them sound like people and not like plot devices. It is the type of scene that the show does best.

Where “Episode Nine” sits in the series

Dark Matter premiered on June 12, 2015, on Space in Canada and Syfy in the United States, on the same day in both countries. The first season ran to thirteen episodes, and the show would go on for three seasons and 39 episodes before Syfy canceled it on September 1, 2017. At episode nine, the series is past its introductory stretch and starting to spend its mystery on relationships, not on reveals.

That shift is why this hour works as a mid-season checkpoint. The previous episodes introduced the crew's histories one by one, including the entertainment android Wendy, played by guest star Ruby Rose, in “Episode Seven.” By episode nine the audience knows the faces and is ready to see how they treat each other when the plot pushes them apart.

02Scene 02

“Episode Nine” at a glance

  • Episode: Season 1, Episode 9, first aired on August 7, 2015, on Syfy.
  • Written by: Joseph Mallozzi. Directed by: Ron Murphy.
  • Focus: Four, who leaves the Raza to meet his brother Hiro and is arrested by his old mentor Akita.
  • Cast: Marc Bendavid (One), Melissa O'Neil (Two), Anthony Lemke (Three), Alex Mallari Jr. (Four), Jodelle Ferland (Five), Roger Cross (Six), Zoie Palmer (the Android).
  • Ending: three Ferrous Corp destroyers disable the Raza's faster-than-light drives.
03Scene 03

Verdict: a quiet episode that fits the show

“Episode Nine” is not a big plot episode, and that is a point in its favor. What Dark Matter does well, and what this hour demonstrates, is balance. The action sequences are competent and the rescue works, but the best material is in the margins: Two and Three discussing muscle memory, One and Three recounting their score, Four and Two talking about family, and every scene with Five or Six. Even the Android's talk with Three about resetting her memory because she is flawed earns its place. That is the core of this Dark Matter episode nine review: the hour is small in scale and consistent in quality.

The ensemble format is a trap for most shows, because it is easy to feature one or two characters and push the rest aside. Dark Matter keeps shining a light on every member of the Raza, which is what makes the episodes feel like chapters in a shared story. This week Four is the focus, but nobody is left out.

The weak point is Two. She is the group's leader and its strongest member, but outside of her decisive handling of the first two episodes she has mostly followed One and Three. She barely shows up in the Four plot until the end, when the group rescues him, and the episode misses a chance to put her in charge. Her secrets seem to be making her cautious, and the show needs to let her lead sooner or later.

For viewers deciding whether to keep watching, this is a good example of what the show is. It is a relaxed space adventure with a warm center, and “Episode Nine” is one of the better entries of the early run.

A last point in its favor: the hour trusts its audience. It does not stop to explain who Hiro is or why Akita matters, and it lets the performances carry the history. Anyone reading a Dark Matter episode nine review before deciding whether to watch can take that as the recommendation.

04Scene 04

Dark Matter episode nine questions, answered

When did Dark Matter episode nine air?

It aired on August 7, 2015, on Syfy. It is the ninth episode of season 1.

Who wrote and directed Dark Matter “Episode Nine”?

Joseph Mallozzi wrote it and Ron Murphy directed it.

What happens in Dark Matter “Episode Nine”?

Four leaves the Raza to meet his brother Hiro and is arrested by his former mentor Akita. The rest of the crew rescues him, and Four then kills Akita as a message to Hiro. The hour ends when three Ferrous Corp destroyers disable the Raza's drives.

Who is Four in Dark Matter?

Four is played by Alex Mallari Jr. His real name is Ishida Ryo, the crown prince of Zairon, and unlike the rest of the crew he remembers his past.

Why do the characters in Dark Matter have numbers for names?

The six crew members woke up on the Raza with no memory, and they named themselves in the order in which they woke up, from One to Six.

What are Five and Six arguing about?

Five asks Six to teach her to defend herself. He refuses because he sees her as a child, and she answers that she has already nearly died for the crew.

Is Dark Matter “Episode Nine” a good place to start the series?

No. It leans on relationships built in the first eight episodes, especially the feud between One and Three, so it is best watched in order.

05Scene 05

Sources

Top